Pages

Monday, March 10, 2014

The Adult Catechumenate


Maître de Hoo
Baptême de catéchumènes
From The Béthune Book of Hours
1430 - 1435
Paint on parchment
18 cm x 13.3 cm
Ms69-folio85
Musée Condé, Chantilly



Girolamo Genga 1476 - 1551
St Augustine baptises the catechumens
1516-1518
Oil on wood panel
91,7 cm x 49,5 cm
Accademia Carrara - Museo, Bergamo

Yesterday by accident I was able to attend one of the two days given over at Westminster Cathedral to the Rite of Christian Initiation for Adults

Over the weekend 712 people from 119 parishes were welcomed by Cardinal Vincent Nichols, the Auxiliary Bishops, along with four Episcopal Vicars and many Deans from the Diocese

Here are some of the photographs of the occasion







It is an unusual rite but yesterday`s ceremony was a joyful one at which to be present and I was glad to have been there

There were so many people from all different backgrounds and ways of life

The singing was of course excellent as usual

It is an old and antique rite and procedure which fell into disuse but was only revived again at the insistence of the Fathers of the Second Vatican Council

In  Sacrosanctum Concilium, the Council stated:
"64. The catechumenate for adults, comprising several distinct steps, is to be restored and to be taken into use at the discretion of the local ordinary. By this, means the time of the catechumenate, which is intended as a period of suitable instruction, may be sanctified by sacred rites to be celebrated at successive intervals of time. 
65. In mission lands it is found that some of the peoples already make use of initiation rites. Elements from these, when capable of being adapted to Christian ritual, may be admitted along with those already found in Christian tradition, according to the norm laid down in Art. 37-40, of this Constitution. 
66. Both the rites for the baptism of adults are to be revised: not only the simpler rite, but also the more solemn one, which must take into account the restored catechumenate. A special Mass "for the conferring of baptism" is to be inserted into the Roman Missal."

The new rite was promulgated by Pope Paul VI in 1972: RCIA: Ordo Initiationis Christianae Adultorum, Rite of Christian Initiations of Adults 

In his Doctoral Thesis, Dr David  Andrew  Pitt researched and wrote about what happened between 1964 and 1972. There are three volumes of his thesis presented to Notre Dame University, Indiana: Revising the Rite of Adult Initiation: The Structural Reform of the Ordo Initiationis Christianae Adultorum, Ordo Catechumenatus per Gradus Dispositus, 1964-1972

They are here

Of special importance in the process of revision has been the work of Abbé Louis Duchesne  and 20th century French and other Northern Western European theologians 

In particular, Balthasar  Fischer,  “The  Rite  of  Christian  Initiation  of  Adults:  Rediscovery  and  New Beginnings,” Worship 64 (1990), 102 said of the new approach and rite:
"it was progress in patristic studies which enabled the Second Vatican Council to  take such a radical approach to the catechumenate, namely, the restoration of the  ancient pattern as it was first set out in the Apostolic Tradition of Hippolytus in the first decades of the third century"
The prototype was "tested" in about fifty "sites" in: Algeria, Ghana, the Ivory Coast, Mali, Togo, Upper Volta, Rwanda, France, Belgium, Quebec, Japan and  the United States

Perhaps it will be looked at again in the forthcoming Synod of Bishops as part of the increased effort towards evangelisation

Saturday, March 08, 2014

Catholics in International Women`s Day

Pieter de Jode 1606-ca. 1674
Portrait of Juliana Morell
c 1626
Print
180 x 123 mm
Biblioteca Nacional de España, Madrid

The inscription reads:
""IVLIANA MORELLA, BARCINONENSIS / Virgo hispana Capuccinorum habitum pietatis ergo gestans, Latinae Graecae et / Hebraeae linguarum perita Philosophiae ac Iurisprudentiae studiosa: Theses philosophicas / anno Christi MDCVI aetatis XIII á se publicé disputas Margaritae Austriae / Hispaniarum Indiarumque Reginae inscripsit & evulgavit. Floret Lugduni / in Gallia, Musicis instrumentis aliisque ingenii Artibus apprime exercita"

Juliana Morell (16 February 1594 – 26 June 1653) was a Spanish Dominican nun, and the first woman to receive a Doctor of Laws degree.



Portrait of Elena Lucrezia Cornaro Piscopia
18th century
Biblioteca Ambrosiana, Milan

Elena Lucrezia Cornaro Piscopia (1646 – 26 July 1684) was a Venetian philosopher of noble descent, and the first woman to receive a university degree.

The English sources do not really do this remarkable woman justice or highlight the scale of her achievements

For Italian sources see

the Biography in Treccani



Carlo Vandi (Bologna d. 1768)
Portrait of Laura Bassi
c 1750
Oil on canvas
Sala dello zodiaco e delle stagioni, Museo di Palazzo Poggi, Bologna

Laura Maria Caterina Bassi (29 November 1711 – 20 February 1778) was an Italian scientist, the first woman in the world to earn a university chair in a scientific field of studies. She received a doctoral degree from the University of Bologna in May 1732, only the third academic qualification ever bestowed on a woman by a European university, and the first woman to earn a professorship in physics at a university in Europe. She was the first woman to be offered an official teaching position at a university in Europe

She was described as "the woman who understood Newton"

She was supported strongly by the Church and in particular by the then Archbishop of Bologna,Prospero Lambertini, later Pope Benedict XIV. Bologna was of course part of the Papal States

Of Bassi it was said:
„Every day she holds public debates in her house, attended by those who are in the mood for discussion, and she fears nobody, and frequently someone, who is not afraid of her, leaves very bewildered and with their horns flattened.‟ (Giampietro Zanotti, writer and sculptor)
An early  Italian  prototype of Margaret Thatcher !


Anna Manzolini 1714 - 1774
Wax portrait model of herself by the artist showing her dissecting a human brain 
Museo di Palazzo Poggi, Bologna
Source: Scienza a Due Voci  

Anna Morandi Manzolini (21 January 1714 – 9 July 1774) was an internationally known anatomist and anatomical wax modeler, as lecturer of anatomical design at the University of Bologna.

On the death of her husband in 1755, she became professor of anatomy Knowledge of her talent in moulding anatomical models spread throughout Europe and she was invited to the court of Catherine II of Russia as well as other royal courts.

The British Royal Society elected her a member and invited her to lecture in London



Maria Pellegrina Amoretti (1756 - 1787)

Maria Pellegrina Amoretti (1756 - 1787) was the third woman in Italy to graduate first from Padua and then Bologna and was the first woman to teach at a University

She was a jurist of international repute and her thesis was on the Roman Law of gifts

Her graduation attracted international attention as can be seen from this book in the Internet Archive: Laurea della signora M. Pellegrina Amoretti cittadina d'Oneglia

There is a fresco of the event in the Cathedral here

Unfortunately she died very young at the age of 31 before her great talent could be fully manifest



Portrait of Clotilde Tambroni
Print
Biblioteca dell'Archiginnasio di Bologna, Italy

Clotilde Tambroni (Bologna, 29 June 1758 – Bologna 2 June 1817), was an Italian philologist, linguist and poet. She was a professor in the Greek language at the University of Bologna in 1793–1798, and a professor in Greek and literature in 1800–1808

Here is her elegy in honour of Bodoni

When the French armies invaded Northern Italy and imposed the Cisalpine Republics, she (as well as Galvani) refused for religious reasons to take the oath of loyalty and was deprived of her chair

The selfless and courageous work of women in the Church will be celebrated  in the Vatican for International Women’s Day.

The few biographies of illustrious and talented women  illustrates that contrary to modern belief the Church has fostered in times gone by the talents of gifts of women in particular in Spain, Northern Italy and other areas where it has had influence

If they are not as well known as they should be, then that is the fault of society in general as well as the Church

From looking at the biographies of the women listed above, a number of questions arise:
Why and how did such women come to the fore at this particular time and at the same time as managing to adhere to the tenets of the then Catholic faith (rather than despite it) ? 
Was this resurgence in the role of women a limited phenomenon or was it more widespread ? (The evidence is that it was probably more widespread but the necessary study and scholarship has not been undertaken) 
Why did the role of women not increase thereafter and indeed would appear to have been snuffed out shortly thereafter and the roles of Bassi and the others forgotten until further advances were made about one hundred years later ? 
Or is it a coincidence that these tender shoots in the rise of the influence of women in Western Europe were along with other institutions apparently trampled underfoot by the Napoleonic armies which swept across and conquered Europe in the aftermath of the French Revolution ? In this connection the biography of Clotilde Tambroni seems instructive

Friday, March 07, 2014

On the Pinnacle


Joseph Mallord William Turner (1775‑1851)
The Temptation on the Pinnacle 
c.1834
Graphite, watercolour and gouache on paper
212 x 160 mm
Tate Britain, London

The third and final temptation endured by Christ in the wilderness is when he is challenged by Satan to throw himself down from the highest pinnacle of the Temple in Jerusalem. 

Turner depicts the moment of Christ's triumph over Satan who can be seen hurling himself away from the scene in anger and frustration.

It prefigures the final victory on the Cross and the Resurrection

The scene by Turner is an illustration for Milton`s Paradise Regained Book IV and the climax of that work:

So saying he [Satan] caught him [Christ] up, and without wing
Of Hippogrif bore through the Air sublime
Over the Wilderness and o're the Plain;
Till underneath them fair Jerusalem,
The holy City, lifted high her Towers, [ 545 ]
And higher yet the glorious Temple rear'd
Her pile, far off appearing like a Mount
Of Alablaster, top't with golden Spires:
There on the highest Pinacle he set
The Son of God, and added thus in scorn: [ 550 ]
There stand, if thou wilt stand; to stand upright
Will ask thee skill; I to thy Fathers house
Have brought thee, and highest plac't, highest is best,
Now shew thy Progeny; if not to stand,
Cast thy self down; safely if Son of God: [ 555 ]
For it is written, He will give command
Concerning thee to his Angels, in thir hands
They shall up lift thee, lest at any time
Thou chance to dash thy foot against a stone.
To whom thus Jesus: also it is written, [ 560 ]
Tempt not the Lord thy God; he said and stood.
But Satan smitten with amazement fell
As when Earths Son Antæus (to compare
Small things with greatest) in Irassa strove
With Joves Alcides and oft foil'd still rose, [ 565 ]
Receiving from his mother Earth new strength,
Fresh from his fall, and fiercer grapple joyn'd,
Throttl'd at length in the Air, expir'd and fell;
So after many a foil the Tempter proud,
Renewing fresh assaults, amidst his pride [ 570 ]
Fell whence he stood to see his Victor fall.
And as that Theban Monster that propos'd
Her riddle, and him, who solv'd it not, devour'd;
That once found out and solv'd, for grief and spite
Cast herself headlong from th' Ismenian steep, [ 575 ]
So strook with dread and anguish fell the Fiend,
And to his crew, that sat consulting, brought
Joyless tryumphals of his hop't success,
Ruin, and desperation, and dismay,
Who durst so proudly tempt the Son of God. [ 580 ]
So Satan fell and strait a fiery Globe
Of Angels on full sail of wing flew nigh,
Who on their plumy Vans receiv'd him soft
From his uneasie station, and upbore
As on a floating couch through the blithe Air, [ 585 ]
Then in a flowry valley set him down
On a green bank, and set before him spred
A table of Celestial Food, Divine,
Ambrosial, Fruits fetcht from the tree of life,
And from the fount of life Ambrosial drink, [ 590 ]
That soon refresh'd him wearied, and repair'd
What hunger, if aught hunger had impair'd,
Or thirst, and as he fed, Angelic Quires
Sung Heavenly Anthems of his victory
Over temptation and the Tempter proud. 

The temptations of Christ in the desert are among the most mysterious passages in the Gospels

Saint Pope John Paul II in one of his catecheses on the subject said:
"Jesus knew that he was sent by the Father to establish God's kingdom in the world of humanity. On the one hand, for this purpose he accepted being tempted in order to take his proper place among sinners. He had already done this at the Jordan, in order to serve as a model for all (cf. St. Augustine, De Trinitate 4:13).  
But on the other hand, by virtue of the Holy Spirit's anointing, he reached into the very roots of sin and defeated the one who is the "father of lies" (Jn 8:44). Thus he willingly went to face the temptations at the start of his ministry, complying with the Holy Spirit's impulse (cf. St. Augustine, De Trinitate 13:13). 
One day when his mission was completed he would proclaim: "Now is the time of judgment on this world; now the ruler of this world will be driven out" (Jn 12:31). On the eve of his passion he would repeat once again: "The ruler of the world is coming; but he has no power over me" (Jn 14:30); rather, "the ruler of this world has been condemned" (Jn 16:33).  
The struggle against the "father of lies" who is the "ruler of this world," begun in the desert, will reach its climax on Golgotha. The victory will come about through the cross of the Redeemer."

Wednesday, March 05, 2014

The Garden of Love



William Blake (28 November 1757 – 12 August 1827)
The Garden of Love in Songs of Experience 
1794
Copy A, plate 45 
Illustrated book of poems
Tate Britain, London

I went to the Garden of Love,
And saw what I never had seen:
A Chapel was built in the midst,
Where I used to play on the green.
And the gates of this Chapel were shut,
And Thou shalt not. writ over the door;
So I turn’d to the Garden of Love,
That so many sweet flowers bore.
And I saw it was filled with graves,
And tomb-stones where flowers should be:
And Priests in black gowns, were walking their rounds,
And binding with briars, my joys & desires.

The poem marks the transition between childhood and adulthood

What was not seen, understood or noticed now suddenly engages the poet`s consciousness and comprehension

For the child, his memory of the place had been "the Garden of Love", an idyll - a place of joy and dreams, a welcoming place  where one played without care or abandon, and filled with flowers whose scent was sweet. A delight for the senses and a young being filled with life and untainted by cares

Now instead there was a chapel, locked against entry, a place of rules and prohibitions, surrounded by graves and the thought of death  and not flowers. Black frocked clergy intrude in the scene clutching thorny briars and no flowers are to be seen and their scent is absent. Still called "the Garden of Love", it is now however a place of little joy and certainly not conducive to vision, the other senses and the imagination. 

What started as a happy remembrance has for the poet turned to disappointment and gloom

The innocence of childhood has given way to the sombreness of experience

What Blake is describing is a journey, a pilgrimage which is life time long and that particular time when childhood gives way to the beginnings of adulthood. The age of discretion

Blake reminds us that without the innocence and joy of childhood within our hearts, our prospects will indeed be bleak

At the age of discretion one`s concept of religion is immature, seeing it as a set of moral rules and commandments and nothing more

It is a fraught time, an exciting time but without proper guidance one where idealism can give way to cynicism or worse. 

It can be a springboard for future spiritual growth or a time of the start of loose meandering, a time where there is no spiritual growth, or a period of stunted  growth or the loss of any sense of the spirit at all



In a talk in Rome in 2003, J. Francis Cardinal Stafford, then President of the Pontifical Council for the Laity spoke of the World Youth Day in Cologne in 2005 and the challenges faced by young people as they embark on their journey. 

He said:
"[F]or young people to make a pilgrimage is to meet the natural human need to see and touch God. To seek the glory of God is no 'light matter' for the Hebrew equivalent of 'glory' in the Old Testament means something 'weighty ' in a person, something which gives one 'importance.' ... 
[P]ilgrimages call the young man and the woman to transcend their person as a moral being and to rediscover man the sinner. A pilgrimage means to go beyond moralism in religion, that caricature of Christianity when it is made reductively into a system of commandments and nothing more. 
The WYD pilgrimage makes evident to young people an all-pervading sense that, even though all the blunders, hypocrisies and even malice of our personal and collective histories have scattered and divided the children of Adam, that is not the end of the story. 
Rather, Christ's mercy at the end has "gathered up the fragments from every side, forged them into the fire of love and welded into one what had been broken" (St. Augustine). ... 
[T] he WYD pilgrimage will teach young people that, despite all human sinfulness and perverse cunning, they can still believe that human nature is one and good and overflowing with possibilities. God's love will reveal to them that human existence is unified and comprehensive. 
Much can be forgiven among those who have "loved much" (Lk 7:47). With each step on the pilgrimage the young pilgrims will be faced with their own fallibility and corruptibility. Likewise, they will be faced with the idiosyncracies and sinfulness of others. 
At the same time, they will learn a greater lesson: that no amount of human inconsistency and deviousness can quite manage to squelch the radiance of what God has created. It is He who is responsible for the intrinsic goodness of human nature."

Tuesday, March 04, 2014

Mistreatment of Bishops



A Bishop maltreated by the laity
From Initial "Q" in Reason 3
From Gratian Decretals 
c 1170-1180
Illuminated manuscript
F. 110, ms. 1287
Bibl. Mazarine, Paris


Mistreatment of bishops has always been popular in the Catholic Church

Among some laity, bishop bashing has always been a popular sport

This can be seen from the 12th century depiction above where we see a bishop being physically assaulted by the laity in the 12th century

So we know there has been a tradition of that for at least 900 years

Nowadays physical maltreatment is not preferred. It tends to be more verbal rather than using one`s hands, fists or feet. But that too has a long tradition as in below. 



A Bishop accused of sins of the flesh by a member of the laity
Initial E of Chapter 2
From Gratian Decretals 
12th century
Illuminated manuscript
f. 083, ms. 0103
Bibl. Municipale, Troyes

Even children and  non-Catholics and those excommunicated got into the act as seen below



Bishop accused by an excommunicated person and a child
Miniature at the beginning of Chapter 4
From Gratian Decretals
c. 1300
Illuminated manuscript
f. 117, ms. 0678
Bibl. Municipale, Reims

It obviously is now part of the job description for bishops: wear protective clothing. Presumably at the induction courses for new bishops there are advanced classes in turning the other cheek

But nowadays there seems to be a rush to judgment abut Bishops and to think badly and express those thoughts in ways which to put it mildly are lacking in charity

In fact they totally lack charity and any sense of justice and proportion

The most recent example is the reaction of certain parts of the Catholic blogosphere to  a recent letter sent by the Bishop of Fort Worth, the Most Rev. Michael Olson, to the President of Fisher More College.

Some of the comments are written by people who seem to be quite seriously deranged

Some of the comments made about the bishop have been untrue, unfair, vicious and personally abusive and offensive

The views of Doctor Taylor Marshall who has first hand knowledge of the situation are to be greatly welcomed. 

Pope Leo XIII in Depuis le jour (1899) had some harsh and trenchant words for this type of behaviour on the part of the clergy which should be recalled as they are just as applicable to the laity. They are words written well before Vatican II and note also the reference to the not exactly "liberal" encyclical Mirari Vos :
"32. Listen, then, to the words addressed by St. Ignatius, the great martyr of Antioch, to the clergy of the primitive Church: 
"Let all obey their Bishops, as Jesus Christ obeyed His Father. In all things touching the sense of the Church do nothing without your Bishop, and as our Lord did nothing but in close union with His Father, so priests, do you nothing without your Bishop. Let all members of the priestly body be united, as all the strings of a harp are united in the instrument." (S. Ign. Ant. Ep. ad Smyrn. 8; idem. ad Magn. 7; idem. ad Ephes. 4.)
33. Should you, on the contrary, act as priests independently of this submission to and union with your Bishops, we would repeat to you the words of our predecessor, Gregory XVI, viz., that "you utterly destroy, as far as in you lies, the order established with a most wise forethought by God, the author of the Church." Encyclical epistle, Mirari vos, August 15, 1832. 
34. Remember, too, beloved sons, that the Church is rightly compared to an army in battle array "sicut castrorum acies ordinata," because it is her mission to combat the enemies, visible and invisible, of God and men's souls. Wherefore did St. Paul recommend Timothy to bear himself "as a good soldier of Jesus Christ?" Now, that which constitutes the strength of an army and contributes most to its victory is discipline and the exact and rigorous obedience of all toward those in command. 
35. Just here zeal out of place and without discretion may easily become the cause of real disaster. Call to mind one of the most memorable facts of sacred history. Certainly neither courage, willingness, nor devotion to the sacred cause of religion were lacking in those priests who gathered round Judas Maccabeus, to fight with him against the enemies of the true God, the profaners of the temple, the oppressors of their nation. 
And yet, releasing themselves from the rules of discipline, they rashly engaged in a combat in which they were vanquished. The Holy Spirit tells us of them "that they were not of the race of those who might save Israel." Why? Because they would obey only their own inspirations, and threw themselves forward without awaiting the orders of their leaders. 
"In die illa ceciderunt sacerdotes in bello, dum volunt fortiter faccre, dum sine consilio exeunt in praelium. Ipsi autem non erant de semine virorum illorum, per quos salus facto est in Israel. "
36. On this point our enemies may serve us for an example. They are well aware that union is strength, "vis unita fortior," so they do not fail to unite close when it comes to attacking the holy Church of Jesus Christ. 
37. If, then, you desire, as you certainly do, beloved sons, that in the formidable contest being waged against the Church by anti-Christian sects and by the city of the evil one, the victory be for God and His Church, it is absolutely necessary for you to fight all together in perfect order and discipline under the command of your hierarchical leaders. 
Pay no heed to those pernicious men who, though calling themselves Christians and Catholics, throw tares into the field of the Lord and sow division in His Church by attacking and often even calumniating the Bishops "established by the Holy Ghost to rule the Church of God." Read neither their pamphlets nor their papers. 
No good priest should in any way lend authority either to their ideas or to their license of speech. Can he ever forget that on the day of his ordination he promised "obedientiam et reverentiam" to his Bishop before the holy altar?"

Monday, March 03, 2014

Carnevale and Lent


Ambrogio Brambilla (1575 - 1595 fl)
Carnevale
1583
Print
Bibliothèque nationale de France, Paris

Ambrogio Brambilla (1575 - 1595 fl)
Quaresima (Lent)
c 1583
Print
250 mm  x  196 mm
The British Museum, London

As well as his topographical prints which are now of great historical value, Ambrogio Brambilla also produced many popular illustrations

The above are two which derive from the Italian Commedia Dell'Arte 

They are in the style of Giuseppe Arcimboldo (1526 ,1527 – July 11, 1593) a fellow Milanese renowned nowadays for his portraits of human heads made up of vegetables, plants, fruits, sea creatures and tree roots

Here the two allegorical portraits show the conflicting and contrasting characters of Carnival  which preceded the more sombre and solemn Quaresima (Lent)

Carnival was the period of the year beginning on roughly the Feast of St Stephen (or 17th January) until Ash Wednesday

Later it was reduced to three days and then finally one - Mardi gras

In the Ambrosian Rite around Milan it lasted until the first Sunday of Lent (an additional four days)

Carnival was a time to forget hardship and fear and the rule bound nature of ordinary life. 

It is of course followed by Lent, not simply a liturgical time but of constant fasting and penitence

In the Commedia, Lent kills off Carnival

After plague hit Milan, St Charles Borromeo banned every form of games, shows, carnival masks and profane spectacle as they were contributory causes of the punishment sent by God

But Venice, Florence and Rome kept up the old traditions 

In and around Milan there was a reaction to the Borromean strictures.

Brambilla founded the Accademia dei Facchini della Val di Blenio in Lombardy in 1560

Its members included artists of the late High Mannerism,  musicians, poets and actors who were rather subversive of the very strict Counter Reformation ethos which prevailed in Lombardy and Northern Italy

And what of circus and carnival today ?

In 2004 there was the VII  International Congress for the Pastoral Care of Circus and Travelling Show People in Rome sponsored by the Pontifical Council for the Pastoral Care of the Migrants and Itinerant People

In its Final Document the Congress painted a rather bleak picture and it said: 

"We live in a world that is rapidly changing. Our way of thinking, our social and religious life and politics are influenced especially by economic factors, new means of education that are more and more globalized, technology and wellbeing for many in the midst of an ocean of world-wide poverty. 
- Their itinerant life in itself is sufficient to make society look on circus and carnival people as being “different”, somewhat marginal. Their work is not generally recognized as a form of culture nor is it appreciated as their means of earning their livelihood. The consequence is that circus and carnival people meet with numerous difficulties not only because of their hard lives, being always on the move, but also because of the obstacles various public authorities put in their path. 
- Their difference in educational standards, their more natural rhythm of life, their social and family structures, their ethnic multiplicity and, at bottom, their great degree of forbearance make it hard for circus and carnival people to understand certain elements of life in today’s society (bureaucracy, social welfare, politics, trade unions, etc.). 
- In this context the education of their children and their progress in schooling is one of the greatest difficulties for these families in a pluralistic society with its growing means of instruction and interchange. In some countries, however, circus people have solved the problem of schooling rather well. They can generally rely on teachers belonging to the public or private education system to give lessons as they move from place to place, which enables their children to complete their schooling. 
- Among the various experiences related, particular interest was attached to a project for the cultural training of teachers and helpers to enable the children and young persons of travelling shows to participate in normal compulsory schooling. The project is being worked out with the collaboration of local authorities, Church bodies and the travelling show people themselves. 
- But urban development is more and more pushing to the periphery the structures that sustain travelling shows, forcing them use unsuitable places, at times downright rubbish dumps. Moreover reciprocal prejudice on both sides intensifies their marginalisation.  
- Then again the serious economic difficulties generally confronting contemporary society are having negative repercussions on the work of circuses and carnivals which, aimed as it is at amusement, is not considered a prime necessity. 
- Again whereas the parish helps the sedentary Christian population to feel that it belongs to a community where it can celebrate and deepen its faith, it is practically impossible for carnival people and even more so for circus people to feel that they belong to a local parish or traditional Church community. 
- Nevertheless such values as the family, the fundamentals of life, sobriety, a serious attitude to work and a certain basic popular religiosity have long remained intact, though they are now being weakened. At all events the world of these itinerant people has its own contribution to make to the Church and society, namely a sense of Providence and solidarity. 
- Finally, since ecumenism is today part of the Church’s being, the circus and carnival have justly been described as “a front-line laboratory for Christian progress in universal fraternity, in ecumenism and in meeting other religions”."
Nowadays it would appear that in many places Carnival has been killed off for good, is totally extinct

Sunday, March 02, 2014

Hadrian`s Confession






Baldassare Peruzzi (1481 – 6 January 1536), Niccolò Tribolo  (1500–7 September 1550) and Michelangelo Anselmi (c. 1492 – c. 1554) and others
The Tomb of Pope Adrian (Hadrian) VI (1523 - 1529)
c 1533 with later additions c 1750
Marble
S. Maria dell’Anima, Rome

Pope Adrian VI appears to be at rest in his tomb in S. Maria dell’Anima in Rome which was commissioned by his close personal friend and confidant, his fellow Dutchman Cardinal Willem van Enckevoirt (1464 – 19 July 1534)

Van Enckevoirt was the only cardinal created by Pope Hadrian in his short pontificate and rests also in the same Church in Rome

The tomb depicts a peacefulness and rest which seeemed to elude the Pope during his Pontificate

Until the election of Saint John Paul II four hundred and fifty five years later, Adriaan Florensz (Boeyens)was the last non-Italian to be elected Pope

The epitaph on his tomb is
 "Proh Dolor! Quantum refert in quae tempora vel optimi cujusque virtus incidat" -

Even the best of men may be born in times unsuited to their virtues
It would appear that he was indeed one of the best of men with many virtues

He took up the task of reforming the church with great earnestness, starting with the Curia, but could accomplish little in the face of opposition by the corruption of members within the Curia and the Italian hierarchy. He also had to deal with the German theologians and the Lutheran reformers, and the Turkish armies.

The first two problems are still with us and are of course on the agenda of Pope Francis today

Another similarity with Saint John Paul II was in the desire to recognise publicly the sins and faults of the Church and its members

The occasions when ecclesiastical authorities – Pope, Bishops, or Councils – have openly acknowledged the faults or abuses which they themselves were guilty of, have been quite rare. 

But it was the reforming Pope Adrian VI who acknowledged publicly in a message to the Diet of Nuremberg of November 25, 1522, “the abominations, the abuses...and the lies” of which the “Roman court” of his time was guilty, “deep-rooted and extensive…sickness,” extending “from the top to the members.” 

Adrian VI deplored the faults of his times, precisely those of his immediate predecessor Leo X and his curia

He wrote:
“Each of us must examine [his conscience] with respect to what he has fallen into and examine himself even more rigorously than God will on the day of his wrath” 
The confession came in  his instruction to Francesco Chieregati,  Bishop of Teramo, his nuncio in Germany, 

Chieregati, on the instructions of the Pope, read it to the assembled Diet in Nuremberg


The relevant pages of the book are these:








According to the historian Pastor, such a public confession was entirely without precedent

A translation given in Foxe`s Book of Martyrs is as follows:
"Further, this you shall say unto them, that we confess ourselves, and deny not, but that God suffereth this persecution to be inflicted upon his church for the sins of men, especially of priests and prelates of the clergy. For certain it is, that the hand of the Lord is not shortened, that he cannot save; but our sins have divided between God and us; and therefore he hideth his face from us that he will not hear us. 
The Scripture testifieth, that the sins of the people do issue out from the sins of the priests. 'And therefore,' saith Chrysostom, 'Christ, going about to cure the sick city of Jerusalem, first entered into the temple, to correct the sins of the priests, like a good physician, which first beginneth to cure the disease from the very root.' 
We know that in this holy see there have been many abominable things of long time wrought and practised; as abuses in matters spiritual, and also excesses in life and manners, and all things turned clean contrary. And no marvel if the sickness, first beginning at the head, that is, at the high bishops, have descended aftewards to inferior prelates. 
All we (that is, prelates of the church) have declined every one after his own way; neither hath there been one that hath done good, no not one. Wherefore need it is, that all we give glory to God, and that we humble our souls to him, considering every one of us from whence he hath fallen; and that every one do judge himself, before he be judged of God in the rod of his fury. 
For the redress whereof you shall insinuate unto them, and promise in our behalf, that in us shall be lacking no diligence of a better reformation, first beginning with our own court: that like as, this contagion first from thence descended into all the inferior parts, so reformation and amendment of all that is amiss, from the same place again, shall take his beginning; whereunto they shall find us so much the more ready, for that we see the whole world so desirous of the same. 
We ourselves, as you know, never sought this dignity, but rather coveted, if we otherwise might, to lead a private life, and in a quiet state to serve God; and also would utterly have refused the same, had not the fear of God, and the manner of our election, and misdoubting of some schism to follow after, have urged us to take it. And thus took we the burden upon us, not for any ambition of dignity, or to enrich our friends and kinsfolks, but only to be obedient to the will of God, and for reformation of the catholic church, and for relief of the poor, and especially for the advancement of learning and learned men, with such other things more as appertaineth to the charge of a good bishop and lawful heir of St. Peter. 
And though all errors, corruptions, and abuses be not straight-ways amended by us, men ought not thereat to marvel. The sore is great, and far grown, and is not single, but of manifold maladies together compacted; and therefore to the curing thereof we must proceed by little and little, first beginning to cure the greater and the most dangerous, lest, while we intend to amend all, we destroy all. 'All sudden mutations,' saith Aristotle, 'in a commonwealth, are perilous;' and, He that wringeth too hard, straineth out blood, Prov. xxx. 
"And whereas in your last letters you wrote, that the princes complain, how this see hath been, and is, prejudicial to their ordinances and agreements, hereunto you shall thus answer: that such excesses, which have been done before our time, ought not to be imputed to us, who always have misliked these derogations; and therefore bid them so assure themselves, that though they had required no such matter, we of our own accord would have refrained the same; partly for that it is good, right, and reason, that every one have that which is due unto him; and partly also that the said noble nation of Germany shall have by us no hinderance, but furtherance rather, so much as in us shall lie to do for them. 
"And as touching the processes which they desired to have removed away a rota, and to be referred down to the parties, you shall signify unto them, that we will gratify them herein as much as honestly we may. But because our auditors are now presently absent from the city, by reason of the plague, we cannot be informed as yet touching the quality of those processes. As soon as they shall return, (which we hope will be shortly,) we shall do in the princes' favour what reasonably we may. 
"Further: whereas we understand, that there be many fresh, flourishing wits in Germany, and many well-learned men, which are not seen unto, but be rejected and unlooked to, while in the mean time, through the apostolical provisions, dignities and promotions are bestowed upon tapsters and dancers, and unfit persons; we will, therefore, that you inquire out what those learned men are, and what be their names, to the intent that when any such vacation of benefices in Germany doth fall, we, of our voluntary motion, may provide for them accordingly. 
For why? we consider how much it is against God's glory, and against the health and the edification of souls, that benefices and dignities of the church have now so long time been bestowed upon unworthy and unable persons."

Unfortunately Adrian`s pontificate drew to a close shortly thereafter and he was succeeded by Clement VII, cousin of Leo X, much to the relief and happiness of many in the Roman Court. 

It required more effort to reform but reform the Church did

The historian, Pastor also thought that the failure of Chieregati was in large measure owing to the timidity and selfishness of the great German prelates who were by no means ready to repeat the humble confession of the Pope

Further, the reaction of the German magnates was not favourable and adverse. They simply wanted a Council and repeated earlier demands more to do with political self interest than a general reformation of morals

It was also used by non-Catholic Christians as a stick to beat the Catholic church in their apologetics for their views.

The precedent was not followed again until Pope Paul VI addressed  the opening of the second session of the Second Vatican Council, and  asked “pardon of God…and of the separated brethren” of the East who may have felt offended “by us” (the Catholic Church), and declared himself ready for his part to pardon offences received. 

In the view of Paul VI, both the request for and offer of pardon concerned solely the sin of the division between Christians and presupposed reciprocity.

In the Second Vatican Council, the Council asked “ pardon of God and of the separated brethren, as we forgive those who trespass against us. It also “deplores certain attitudes that sometimes are found among Christians” and which led people to think that faith and science are mutually opposed. 

It also reflected that in “the genesis of atheism,” Christians may have had “some responsibility” insofar as through their negligence they “conceal rather than reveal the authentic face of God and religion.” 

Most importantly the Council “deplored” the persecutions and manifestations of anti-Semitism “in every time and on whoever’s part"

Saint John Paul II reflected and admitted fault on a good number of occasions: to Moravians in his Homily for the Canonization of Jan Sarkander in the Czech Republic, May 21, 1995; Discourse to the participants in the International Symposium of study on the Inquisition, sponsored by the Historical-Theological Commission of the Central Committee of the Jubilee; the Apostolic Letter Tertio millennio adveniente and many other times

As Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI commissioned and published a Report by the International Theological Commission entitled The Church and the Faults of the Past (1999) which recommended the public confession for errors and omissions

To date there has been no greater confession of errors and failings on the part of the Church than Pope Benedict XVI`s Letter to the Catholics of Ireland

Saturday, March 01, 2014

Dürer and the Emperor`s Prayerbook


Albrecht Dürer (1471-1528)
Portrait of Emperor Maximillian I
1519
Oil on panel
74 x 61.5 cm
Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna

Maximilian I (22 March 1459 – 12 January 1519), the son of Frederick III, Holy Roman Emperor and Eleanor of Portugal, was King of the Romans (also known as King of the Germans) from 1486 and Holy Roman Emperor from 1508 until his death

It was he who was responsible for the massive expansion of the House of Habsburg which came to dominate the Europe of his time

His grandson Charles succeeded Maximilian as Holy Roman Emperor in 1519, and ruled  both the Holy Roman Empire and the Spanish Empire simultaneously

He extended the rule of the Habsburgs to the Netherlands, Spain, Bohemia, Hungary, Poland, and Italy.

His reign saw the first flourishing of the Renaissance in Germany. 

He used the arts not simply for his delectation and that of the Court but to consolidate and enhance his rule over his vast empire in  Europe

But he also wished to secure his posthumous fame. 

Albrecht Dürer, Albrecht Altdorfer and Lucas Cranach were but three of the many jewels in this magnate`s treasury to effect such a project



His empire and wealth are gone. 

His dynasty but a shadow of its former glory. He is dust. He is but a memory, unknown outside  a small band of scholars and in museums and art galleries where his paintings hang shorn of any of the meaning and triumphalism which he wanted and commissioned. 

But we have his prayer book

The prayer book of Emperor Maximilian I (Oratio ad suu[m] proprium angelu[m] ) is a prayer book in the Latin language printed in Augsburg in 1514/15 with a run of ten specimens. 

The Bayerische Staatsbibliothek in Munich has now digitised its unique specimen with illustrations by Albrecht Dürer and Lucas Cranach the Elder.

What was seen only by the Emperor and his close family and associates can now be seen by the multitude, the descendants of the burghers, villeins and serfs who inhabited his domains and called him or had to call him "Lord"

We see what he and his closest saw when they prayed


Frontispiece (Albrecht Dürer)



Prayer to Saint Barbara (part of)  (Drawing by Albrecht Dürer)



Prayer to Saint George (Drawing by Albrecht Dürer)



Memento mori (Drawing by Albrecht Dürer)

















Pope Benedict XVI in a discussion about Purgatory, Hell and Eternal Life  in Spe Salvi said this:
"47. Some recent theologians are of the opinion that the fire which both burns and saves is Christ himself, the Judge and Saviour. The encounter with him is the decisive act of judgement. 
Before his gaze all falsehood melts away. 
This encounter with him, as it burns us, transforms and frees us, allowing us to become truly ourselves. All that we build during our lives can prove to be mere straw, pure bluster, and it collapses. 
Yet in the pain of this encounter, when the impurity and sickness of our lives become evident to us, there lies salvation. His gaze, the touch of his heart heals us through an undeniably painful transformation “as through fire”. 
But it is a blessed pain, in which the holy power of his love sears through us like a flame, enabling us to become totally ourselves and thus totally of God. In this way the inter-relation between justice and grace also becomes clear: the way we live our lives is not immaterial, but our defilement does not stain us for ever if we have at least continued to reach out towards Christ, towards truth and towards love. 
Indeed, it has already been burned away through Christ's Passion. 
At the moment of judgement we experience and we absorb the overwhelming power of his love over all the evil in the world and in ourselves. The pain of love becomes our salvation and our joy. 
It is clear that we cannot calculate the “duration” of this transforming burning in terms of the chronological measurements of this world. The transforming “moment” of this encounter eludes earthly time-reckoning—it is the heart's time, it is the time of “passage” to communion with God in the Body of Christ"

What we are looking at in the prayer book is what survives and remains after the blast furnace of time and history and the encounter with the Risen One. It is a depiction of the eternal heartbeat